RFP Questions & Answers
Question 1: We noticed that some addresses do not recall snow removal services. Is this correct?
ANSWER: Please confirm with the Redevelopment Authority of the City of York (RDA) that snow removal is required only for properties specifically identified as requiring snow services in Exhibit A. Proposers would need to determine the scope of snow-removal areas through site inspections, which the RFP strongly encourages prior to proposal submission.
Question 2: May a proposer bid as the prime contractor with a named, insured subcontractor performing the field work?
ANSWER: Yes. A proposer may submit a proposal as the prime contractor while identifying a named and properly insured subcontractor to perform field operations, as the RFP contains no provision prohibiting such arrangements. The prime contractor shall remain responsible for overall contract administration, supervision, performance, and compliance with all contractual and insurance requirements.
Question 3: Would the prime contractor be permitted to manage scheduling, quality checks, reporting, and invoicing while remaining responsible to the Authority for performance?
ANSWER: Yes. The prime contractor may serve as the contract administrator, managing scheduling, quality assurance inspections, reporting, invoicing, and client communications, while utilizing a sub-contractor to perform field operations. The prime contractor would remain fully accountable to the Redevelopment Authority (RDA) of the City of York for contract performance, compliance, with specifications, insurance requirements and satisfactory completion of all services.
Question 4: Are there any self-performance requirements?
ANSWER: No. The RFP does not contain any self-performance requirement or minimum percentages of work that must be performed by prime contractor. A proposer may use subcontractors to perform the fieldwork, provided the prime contractor remains responsible for contract performance and compliance.
Question 5: Are there any limits on subcontracting or approval requirements for subcontractors?
ANSWER: No. There are not any limits imposed on subcontracting, require prior approval of subcontractors, or establish any subcontractor qualification or disclosure requirements.
Question 6: Can the named subcontractor’s experience be used to meet the qualification requirements?
ANSWER: The proposer can rely on the experience, qualifications, references, and operational capabilities of a name subcontractor that will perform the contracted services. Such experience should be clearly presented within the proposal and tied to the subcontractor’s defined role in the contract’s performance.
Question 7: Can the subcontractor’s equipment and staffing be used to meet the qualification requirements?
ANSWER: Yes. The RFP does not require that equipment or personnel be owned or employed by the prime contractor. Therefore, the equipment, staffing, and operational resources of a named subcontractor may be presented to satisfy the proposal’s equipment and staffing requirements, provided the prime contractor remains responsible for overall contract performance.
Question 8: Can the subcontractor’s three comparable client references be used to meet the qualification requirements?
ANSWER: Yes. The RFP does not restrict the use of a named subcontractor’s comparable client references. Accordingly, the three comparable client references of a named subcontractor may be submitted to satisfy the qualification requirements, provided the subcontractor is identified as part of the proposed service team.
Question 9: What documentation or written commitment should the proposal include for the subcontractor?
ANSWER: The RFP does not specify any required subcontractor commitment documentation. Nevertheless, if the proposal relies upon the subcontractor’s qualifications, personnel, equipment, or references, the proposer should include a signed Letter of Commitment or similar written acknowledgement confirming the subcontractor’s participation and availability for the contract term.
Question 10: What insurance must the prime contractor carry?
ANSWER: The successful contractor must maintain General Liability insurance with limits of not less than $1,000,000 per occurrence, Automobile Liability insurance, and Workers Compensation insurance as required by Pennsylvania law, and must name the Redevelopment Authority of the City of York as additional insured.
Question 11: What insurance must the subcontractor carry?
ANSWER: All stated insurance obligations apply to the successful prime contractor.
Question 12: Should both firms name the City and the Authority as additional insureds?
ANSWER: Yes. The successful contractor’s insurance policies must name both the City of York Redevelopment Authority and the City of York as additional insureds. The RFP does not impose this requirement on subcontractors.
Question 13: When must certificates of insurance be provided?
ANSWER: The RFP requires a successful contractor to provide certificates of insurance demonstrating the required coverage at the time the contract is awarded.
Question 14: The Exhibit A list appears to identify 33 properties for snow service. Is this the complete snow removal scope?
ANSWER: No. While Exhibit A identifies the properties currently designated for snow removal services, the RFP does not represent that list as a fixed or complete scope. The RDA expressly reserves the right to add or remove properties during the contract term.
Question 15: Must a proposal cover all 33 properties?
ANSWER: No. THE RFP does not expressly require proposers to submit pricing for all properties listed in Exhibit A. However, because the solicitation is silent on partial-property awards, proposers should seek clarification from the RDA if they intend to bid on only a subset of the listed properties.
Question 16: Is there a map or list identifying which properties require lot or driveway plowing in addition to sidewalk clearing?
ANSWER: The RFP does not provide a map or property-by-property breakdown identifying which locations require parking lot or driveway plowing in addition to sidewalk clearing. Proposers would need to determine the scope of snow-removal areas through site inspections, which the RFP strongly encourages prior to proposal submission.
Question 17: Should per-plow and seasonal rates be submitted as two separate pricing options?
ANSWER: Yes. The pricing table requests a “Cost per Plow” and a “Seasonal Cost” and then separately state that contractors may alternatively submit annual fixed-fee pricing with details of included services.
Question 18: How should standalone deicing services be priced?
ANSWER: THE RFP does not provide a separate pricing line item for standalone deicing services. Rather, it states that labor and equipment costs for ice control are to be included in the contractor’s minimum price for each property, indicating that deicing should be incorporated into the submitted snow removal pricing unless otherwise proposed as an alternative pricing structure.
Question 19: How should return visits for refreeze be priced?
ANSWER: The RFP does not establish separate pricing for return visits due to refreeze conditions. As written, the contractor’s pricing should include labor, equipment, and operational costs necessary to monitor and treat refreeze conditions as required under the contract.
Question 20: Is the initial snow service term January 1 through March 31, 2027?
ANSWER: Yes. Based on the anticipated award and contract commencement dates, the initial snow removal service period would run from January 1, 2027, through March 31, 2027. Subsequent renewals would encompass the full November 1 through March 31 snow season.
Question 21: What is the required invoicing schedule?
ANSWER: Terms and specifics will be addressed when the contract is awarded.
Question 22: What is the expected payment timing after acceptance of services?
ANSWER: Terms and specifics will be addressed when the contract is awarded.
Question 23: Is a sample agreement available for review?
ANSWER: No. The RFP does not include a sample agreement or draft contract for proposers to review. Accordingly, no agreement and any additional contractual terms are not provided in the solicitation documents.